Log In
Sign Up and Get Started Blogging!
JoeUser is completely free to use! By Signing Up on JoeUser, you can create your own blog and participate on the blogs of others!
voo's domain
We swears to serve the master of the precious.
[POLL] WB or VS?
Published on April 21, 2003 By
voo
In
WinCustomize Talk
http://www.neowin.net/forum/index.php?s=4bfc1f48a15d92a70c858da5fd646731&act=ST&f=62&t=73903&st=15
What Do You Prefer..
Popular Articles in this Category
Post your favorite youtube clips!
March 2024 Desktop Screenshots
April 2024 Desktop Screenshots
Ads?
Popular Articles from voo
Comments (Page 1)
2 Pages
1
2
Next
1
Stumpy
on Apr 21, 2003
WB obviously
2
paxx
on Apr 21, 2003
Well, asked here, most people would answer Windowblinds.
Brad, hehehe! About your post on that messageboard, I do remember a poll asking the same question here. Oops! hehehe! (Poll ID #36, if you want to check yourself)
3
Frogboy
on Apr 21, 2003
Paxx: Exactly my point.
WHERE a poll is given makes a big difference. That's why I made that poll here at the time, to make that point.
I find the amount of trolling done by msstyles people to be rather bizarre. It's almost as if they're trying to convince themselves that their patch is better than an actual skinning program.
But it's much weirder than that. What exactly is the psychology of rooting for Microsoft to kill off small third party developers? Talk about rooting for the over-dog.
Imagine this scenario:
Our new game, GalCiv is #3 on Amazon.com. It's already grossed into the 7 digit range in < 1 month since release. Now, imagine if enough people had switched to using msstyles and WindowBlinds was just not making that much money any more and we just threw up our hands and said "Screw this, we're done."
Then Longhorn comes out and lo and behold, msstyles no longer work. It's dead. Bye bye msstyles. And there's nothing there to replace it. Who knows. I do know msstyles are gone in Longhorn. Will something replace it? Maybe, maybe not. Imagine if they don't though and there's a decent chance of that. So all these msstyles advocates would suddenly no longer be able to skin. It would be like being back to Windows 2000 again. Imagine if they broke WindowBlinds too so that wasn't a choice.
Do they really think some freeware author is going to create some sort of skinning thing from scratch? It took us 3 years of devleopment, by paid developers, to create WindowBlinds. And we didn't have to deal with Paledium or any of the other security stuff coming up.
The point is, rooting for the over-dog (Microsoft in this instance) seems just plain insane. Anyone who wants to change the way Windows looks by default should be hoping, at the very least, that the third parties (whether that be Stardock or Nullsoft or whomever) do well enough to keep at it.
To use an analogy:
Ever see the movie "Tucker"? About the company that was making cars that were really ahead of their time? One has to wonder who, watching that film woudl be rooting for the big 3 over Tucker. "Screw Tucker! Their innovation just makes things non standard. We don't need no freaking anti-lock breaks or fuel injection!"
4
GhoS
on Apr 21, 2003
I agree there needs to be room for innovation if OS's and computers are to continue to grow. MS has had a very bad habit of doing things well enough to cause trouble for 3rd party developers, and once they dominate, they stop innovating. I for one sure hope StarDock can continue to help us create our desktops the way we want them. MS can design them for the masses, but leave the real art to those of us who don't want to be like everyone else.
5
elvee
on Apr 21, 2003
WB4 without question
6
kona0197
on Apr 21, 2003
did anyone ever stop to think that uxtheme.dll is easier to use than WB and it sytlexp does not suck down memory?
7
kona0197
on Apr 21, 2003
BTW it looks like longhorn will incorperate uxtheme.dll by letting people dl themes for the OS. read that at a live chat microsoft had.
8
Frogboy
on Apr 21, 2003
I know for a fact .msstyles won't be supported. The best you can hope for is that someone will write a converter and it's not apparent whether that will be posisble.
As for "Themes", yes, there will be themes for Longhorn but not the way you're thinking. They want to make it so that you can have like the classic look with themes but with the Longhorn look. They're not talking about skinning.
9
paxx
on Apr 21, 2003
Err, kona.
*Meep* Wrong answer.
Windowblinds uses less memory than StyleXP or the "native" XP skinning engine.
*Meep* Wrong answer.
uxtheme.dll is not easier to use since it's a system hack and you have to reinstall a new version everytime Microsoft overwrites it with a system patch. Besides, I will never install a skin from people I don't know that are executables, and all MSSTYLES I've seen are in executable format. Highly dangerous. I don't call that easier.
10
kona0197
on Apr 21, 2003
BUT ...
Style XP takes the place of DX, OB, OD, WB, and weblinds. It's a all in one program. That's why people like it. If you take OB, OD, DX, WB, and weblinds, it will take more memory than styleXP
11
paxx
on Apr 21, 2003
You ARE kidding, right?
Style XP does NOTHING that Desktop, Objectbar or Object Dock does. What are you talking about? Come on, get real.
12
moshi
on Apr 21, 2003
kona: sorry that´s complete nonsense.
btw: uxtheme.dll is not something you "use". it´s just a patched system file. and how often did MS overwrite it? one time?
paxx: i hope you stay away of DesktopX and it´s support for scripting languages as well. there´s some really nasty stuff that can be done with these.
13
kona0197
on Apr 21, 2003
yes it does. it changes all the scroll bars. it take webblinds and windowsblinds to do that. It also changes the taskbar.
14
paxx
on Apr 21, 2003
Really?
I don't use Desktop X a lot, but I didn't know that. I thought Deskscript was hardly more dangerous than Javascript.
15
paxx
on Apr 21, 2003
Desktscript = DX Script. ahem.
2 Pages
1
2
Next
Welcome Guest! Please take the time to register with us.
There are many great features available to you once you register, including:
Richer content, access to many features that are disabled for guests like commenting on the forums.
Access to a great community, with a massive database of many, many areas of interest.
Access to contests & subscription offers like exclusive emails.
It's simple, and FREE!
Sign Up Now!
Meta
Views
» 8185
Comments
»
25
Category
»
WinCustomize Talk
Comment
Recent Article Comments
I need a joke today
LightStar Design Windowblind...
Climate Change Zealots
Let's start a New Jammin Thr...
v2.5 & Warlords Expansion Gu...
Quick thoughts on Warlords f...
AI Desktop Wallpaper 2023
Are there any high quality O...
The Forum feature / improvem...
Saying "Hi"
Sponsored Links